Skip to main content

Socratic seminar to talk about novels

 When you discuss a novel with students, especially a long one and/or in parts, in never cease to look for inspiration for new ideas how to go about the book in an engaging and thought- provoking way.

Ever heard of Socratic seminar or Socratic circles ? They go a long way, but it I only recently have discovered them.


What is it?

It basically a formal discussion based on a text, where students show and deepen their understanding of the ideas in the text through asking questions, answering them, observing others take part in a discussion, as well as reflecting on their performance and cognitive processes, communication and conclusions drawn. The beauty of it is that it allows students to engage with the text, to construct knowledge through collaboration, practice active listening and be reflective. 

What does it look like?

Students are divided into two groups, one of them forms the inner circle, the other is the outer circle. These could as well be squares, as long as students are facing ach other. The inner circle takes a set amount of time (eg 20 minutes) to discuss questions relating to the text they all read before. The questions are prepared and asked by the members of the outer circle who observes the discussion and takes notes. Then the circles switch and the process starts again.

Variations/;

 There are some variations on how to conduct the discussion- some teachers like to be or appoint a discussion leader or reserve a hot seat for a student form the outer circle to join the discussion should there be a need; some teachers prepare a fishbowl of questions, some ask students from the outer circle to just take turns and ask them; some teachers don't even have the outer circle, just the discussion one...I guess it is up to you, which variations you go for, as long as they work for you and your students:)

Preparation:

1. Students read the text, prepare questions and find quotations (see for example  this handout)

2. The ground rules for discussion (as in the picture above) are explained as well as  the rules for this type of discussion established

3. The teacher prepares a post discussion refection sheet, asking students to prove they were listening closely to the discussion and show their thinking, as well as reflect on what they could improve the next time (try this handout)

4. The discussion is evaluated based on some rubric (like this one)- it is a great opportunity for peer-assessment or self evaluation!

Obviously, the rubric the prep sheet and the debrief sheet might differ from group to group and from topic to topic, it depends what you want to discuss. specifically.


Just a side note, hope you don’t mind......

If you like my content, maybe you would like to support me and buy me coffee?

Also, you might want to check other materials I create for the English Bilingual Secondary Classes (C1) - I am sure some of them will be useful for the English B HL classes, for example BritSpeak or OpenBookCouples. 

Check out the shop at dwujezycznie.pl


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

HONY, honey:)

  There is a book, fb page, lots of articles, videos, interviews, lesson ideas on HONY- Humans of New York, and now there is also my extensive lesson plan-... Never heard of it? Humans of New York (HONY) is a popular photography project and storytelling  blog created in 2010 by Brandon Stanton. It started as a simple goal to photograph  10,000 people living in New York City, but evolved into a powerful collection of  portraits and personal stories. Each photo is paired with a short interview or quote  that reveals intimate, honest, and often surprising details about the subject's life. Over time, the project expanded beyond New York to include stories from many countries, covering diverse experiences and social issues. HONY offers a unique window into the lives of everyday people, encouraging empathy and understanding through storytelling. Interested? Check out  this handout    for reading, listening, writing and speaking ideas. Just a side note, ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Have yourself a "less-is-more" Christmas....

Every year, the same film plays on repeat. Black Friday hits, and people who swore they were “cutting back this year” are suddenly refreshing carts at midnight, chasing countdown timers and “only 3 left!” banners. This was the starting point for my minimalism lesson: if students are already swimming in Black Friday ads and Christmas wish lists, why not turn that chaos into something reflective and language‑rich?  The heart of the plan is a “Less Is More” advent calendar that runs parallel to the shopping season. While the outside world shouts “Buy! Hurry! More!”, students open a different kind of window each day: deleting unused apps, clearing one surface, designing an experience gift instead of buying another object. Each task comes with a guided question and a pair of chunky expressions to use in a short English reflection, so language development and behaviour change grow together. In  this handout  Black Friday and Christmas haven’t disappeared, but the spell is weake...
1 comment
Read more

Dead Poets Society Lesson

“ Let’s watch a movie! ” We’ve all been there- usually on a rainy Tuesday when the caffeine is failing and the class morale needs a jumpstart. However, we know the "movie day" stigma. A film is only a great lesson if the actual learning matches the energy of the screen. For my money, there is no better choice than Dead Poets Society. It is the ultimate catalyst for talking about the big stuff: identity, rebellion, and the purpose of education. I’ve mapped out a series of lessons that go way beyond just "watching."  We’re talking: • Silent Discussions (for the deep thinkers) • Film Review Writing • A Mock Trial of Mr. Keating   Carpe Diem! Check out the full plan below and let me know what you think  DeadPoetsSocietyLessonPlan Just a side note, hope you don’t mind...... If you like my content, maybe you would like to support me and  buy me coffee ? Also, you might want to check other materials I create for the English Bilingual Secondary Classes (C1) - I am sure som...
Post a Comment
Read more